The
hierarchical social structure which emerged on Crete around 2,000 BCE
grew in parallel with localized hierarchical architecture. The
dominant building in any Minoan and Mycenaean town was its central
Palace Temple. Since there is no written explanation as to the
function of the structure, it was originally considered by Arthur
Evans to be a palace. Later archeologists have pointed out the
multitude of ritual scenes and cult objects within the structure,
leading many (such as Rodney Castleden) to believe the building is a
grand temple. It is also possible that it served multiple purposes,
being the symbolic focal point for both the secular and religious
hierarchy, and possibly even a necropolis. Other regional
civilizations built large temples which helped centralize the urban
secular and religious authority. In nearby Anatolia, the Hittites
built a large temple in their capital Hattusa, and in Mesopotamia the
most powerful city states each had their own megalithic ziggurat. The
division of power in such societies is not quite clear, with the
power of each authority varying by culture and period. In Egypt there
is evidence that priests were sent to conduct trade deals, so there
was some crossover between religious and secular duties.
|
The Temple at Knossos, from ancientlights.org |
The
first temples were built through the 20th century BCE
lasted til around 1,700 BCE, when an earthquake destroyed most
everything on the island, ending the Old Temple period. Minoans would
stand resilient in the face of such devastation, as each city rebuilt
their temple and life went on. Thus the New Temple period began and
temples increased in their structural complexity. Ambitious planners
took advantage of their opportunity to re-envision old traditions,
and to re-solidify old power structures. New ideas spread during the
NT period, a new style of pottery called the Marine style dominated
the Minoan art world. This New Temple period lasted from 1,700 til
around 1,470, brought to a brutal end by the Theran eruption. Dating
this eruption is problematic, with many dates ranging from
1,600-1,400, I'm using Rodney Castleden's dating for the sake of
simplicity. The eruption not only wiped the Minoan colony of Thera
off the map, but brought earthquakes and floods to the rest of the
Minoan heartland. The Minoans were not destroyed by this calamity,
but they were shaken to their core. This brutal disaster brought an
end to the NT period and to their ancestral power structures.
|
“The Demise of the Minoans” by Aaron John Gregory |
|
Differing design plans of the OT palaces (on the top) and the NT palaces (on the bottom) at Knossos, Phaistos, and Mallia |
Once
again, the slate was wiped clean, but this time only one city managed
to rebuilt their temple: Knossos. For about 90 years, from the 1,470
Theran eruption until about 1,380 (or from 1,600-1,510 or
1,450-1,360), the only large city with a palace-temple was Knossos.
Most likely this good fortune afforded its Wanax dominance over
neighboring rivals, possibly the whole island. In 1,380 a fire
destroyed the Knossian temple for the 3rd time, and this
layer was its last, as it was never rebuilt. The ancient urban core
of the city was mostly abandoned, and the last remaining temple
hierarchy finally collapsed. Sadly, Arthur Evans' destructive and
clumsy excavations permanently destroyed much of our ability to
reconstruct the temple's layout during Knossos' final glory, although
there is much more to be said about Arthur Evans later. At least he
did not use dynamite, as Heinrich Schliemann did at Troy.
“Evans had stripped most of the palace down to its MMIII to LMI
skeleton [1,700-1,450 BCE], so that its later plan is
now difficult to reconstruct.” - Colin Macdonald
The
final abandonment of Knossos around 1,370 BCE was also due to the
city's lowland placement. The LBA period was rife with disorder and
warfare, the old maryannu order was collapsing all across the Aegean.
During this period the large valley cities were abandoned as Minoan
society reformed its manner of urban planning. Slowly, over the
course of centuries they eventually forgot they had ever changed.
Looking down from their defensive mountain holds onto the ruins of
vast cities, after a few generations did any Cretan remember their
glorious past?
|
A colorful reconstruction of the interior of a Mycenaean palace-temple |
The
Minoan palace system created three general variations of
palace-temples. The first generation or Old Temple period from
2,000-1,700 BCE,
the second generation or New Temple period from 1,700-1,450 BCE,
and the third generation or Knossian period from 1,450-1,380 BCE.
Each generation of temples
was structured differently, and those who lived inside such temples
viewed the world from three temporally separate worldviews.
The largest temple which ever
existed was Knossos during its period of solitary dominance, and
analyzing that structure can help us understand the general
underlying themes of usage from such buildings.
Inside
the Labyrinth
|
The Bull and Tree fresco at Knossos |
The
extant temple palace at Knossos represents its latest iteration,
completed around 1,400 BCE at the height of Knossian'
LM dominance. It is the largest Minoan building ever built, standing
140 meters on each side (covering 20,000 meters). Its design reveals
its prior NT (New Temple)
era plan, it
was built from the inside-out in step by step agglomerative fashion
without an original master plan. Its
structure is reminiscent of a labyrinth, a multitude of intricate
corridors and rooms, towering up to four stories tall. Around 300
ground floor rooms survive, including stairways off the main court.
|
The plaza area outside the palace-temple |
One
fundamental purpose of the structure was to house its countryside's
produce, and each palace had long narrow storerooms filled with large
pithoi jars. At Phaistos and Mallia well paved sections surround the
massive granaries, suggesting these objects were focal points and saw
heavy foot traffic. Presumably
these areas were another focus of the structure, possibly places were
public ceremonies occurred. Although
food storage is evidenced, it is important to note that many doubt
the grain aspect
of the granaries, and people such as Ian Swindale estimates that food
storage in temples was reserved only for workers and feasts, and not
redistributive taxation.
|
A person standing next to a pithos storage jar |
|
A narrow storage passageway with pithoi jars |
|
A large pithos jar covered with handles |
The
Wings of the Temple, The West Wing
|
Knossos labyrinth with details |
|
Detailed interior plan of the temple with rooms labeled |
|
The Priest King fresco in situ at Knossos |
The
west side of the Knossos labyrinth housed Cretan hieroglyphic
tablets, storage, and cultic rooms, and was probably the
administrative center. This section also includes the most famous
room uncovered by Evans: The Throne Room. In this room, a stone seat
sits centered on a wall, flanked by altar benches and painted
geometric griffons. Sitting before the throne is a stone offering
bowl. The throne room is low, without windows, and symbolically
private. It is connected to the central court, but separated by an
anteroom. This mysterious room was not actually the king's chambers
(as Evans thought), but served a cultic purpose as an adyton (a
restricted sacred space). A priestess representing a goddess would
have sat on the throne, the focus of a specific devotional practice.
|
The Throne |
|
The Throne Room |
|
Plan of the Throne Room Suite (after Evans, Palace of Minos IV, figure 877) |
|
Drawing of the Throne by Theodore Fyfe |
|
Detail of a griffon fresco in the Throne Room |
Continuing
deeper into the labyrinth, off of the throne room are two exits: one
leading to 9 rooms and the other to storage. This cluster of rooms
beginning with the throne room were probably considered separate from
the general temple, and the throne room itself was probably the
cultic focal point of the temple.
|
Reconstruction of the full Throne Room |
|
Looking outside from the Throne Room |
Deep
within the west wing of the labyrinth was a crypt, filled with
pillars. On these pillars were multiple double axe motifs, symbols of
both the Minoans central goddess and of execution. Under the floor of
this room were the ashes of presumably sacrificed animals. Beside the
pillars were rectangular depressions for offerings. Blood sacrifice
was rife within the Minoan religion, and the executioner's axe was a
sacred symbol of power.
In
addition to the throne room, the administrative west wing includes
the snake goddess sanctuary. This room housed multiple snake goddess
statuettes which have become the most famous object associated the
Minoan culture. They were buried within cysts in the floor of the
room. One figurine was intentionally broken in half for some purpose
prior to its deposition.
|
Items found by Evans in the Snake Goddess Sanctuary |
|
A faience snake goddess figurine from the Snake Goddess Sanctuary |
|
A stone cross found in the Snake Goddess Sanctuary |
The
west wing also includes the cup bearer sanctuary, with its vivid
life-sized fresco of a servant/celebrant.
|
Reconstruction of the Cup Bearer fresco in situ at Knossos |
Another
important room in the west wing is the great sanctuary. This room is
abnormally large (16 meters cross) with a large window and the famous
bull leaping fresco. During ceremonies a priestess representing a
goddess would appear in such windows, this integral aspect along with
the elaborate fresco points to this room's importance.
|
Reconstruction of the Bull Leaping fresco |
The
North Wing
The
north section of the labyrinth holds the north pillar hall, connected
to the outside by a small doorway. This section also held
administrative tablets. There is a long passageway leading from the
north pillar hall to the central court, which was covered by the NT
period although probably uncovered in the OT period. Also in the
north section is the bull chamber with its bull leaping fresco. The
north east section of the palace contained store rooms as well as
clay cups, most likely an area where meals were eaten or prepared.
Sadly the north east section was badly damaged in Arthur Evan's
excavation.
|
Columns at the temple at Knossos |
|
A screenshot from the game Depths of Fear, set in a fantastical version of the Knossian labyrinth. While not an actual intended reconstruction the design resembles the uncovered north wing passageway in the OT period |
|
A courtyard at Knossos, from yurdigital.com |
The
East Wing
The
east side housed storage but most prominently over 400 loom weights
suggesting an in-temple workshop, although these rooms also included
altar benches. After the great earthquake around 1,700 the eastern
section's storerooms were filled in and used as a foundation for its
NT era purpose. In the east wing originally there were four levels,
two beneath the ground level and one above. Luckily for us, only the
top level was destroyed. The walls of the ground level east wing
rooms are quite thick, suggesting knowledgeable architectural
planning. The second floor of the east wing housed the sanctuary of
the great goddess, which had collapsed onto the ground floor. Many
cultic objects were recovered from this room, including a small three
pillar shrine, altars, sacred horns, and bronze hair from a statue.
This goddess statue was 3 meters high. The sanctuary of the great
goddess was connected to the central court by a flight of twelve
stairs.
|
Similar loom weights to ones found at Knossos, these are from building 4 at the palace at Arkhanes, Crete |
|
Arthur Evan's “Gallery”, reconstructed during his excavations |
|
Reconstruction of the Hall of the Shields at Knossos |
|
Picture of the Hall of the Shields fresco at Knossos |
By
far, the most impressive section of the east wing is the grand
staircase, containing 54 steps descending four levels to the hall of
the double axes.
|
Diagram of the grand staircase at Knossos |
|
A picture from the top of the grand staircase at Knossos |
|
The courtyard at the bottom of the grand staircase, from crete-kreta.com/knossos |
At
the bottom of the grand staircase the hall of the double axes was
most likely a cultic area. It was very private and intentionally set
back from public areas, being one of the most internally closed off
rooms. It should also be mentioned, that it was near crafting rooms
which may have been noisy or may suggest a different purpose for the
hall of the double axes. The hall has two sections, an inner and an
outer chamber. The inner chamber could be closed off by 11 sets of
double doors, and a similar deeply recessed room was found at
Phaistos. While the activities done in this room are unknown, its
extreme privacy points to its function as an adyton. Near the hall of
the double axes is the beautiful dolphin sanctuary. The dolphin
sanctuary was adjoined to a lustral basin, and both the adjoining
room and the sanctuary itself had an unknown purpose.
|
Reconstruction of the dolphin fresco |
|
Picture of the dolphin fresco |
|
Detail of the dolphin fresco |
Life
in the Temple
Its
labyrinthine allusions are tempered by reminders of everyday life. A
miniature fresco shows a temple with netting hung over the windows,
presumably to keep out birds. Although the dove was a religious
symbol, the practical concerns of ceremonies took precedence. Temples
also generally had entire suites of chambers separated from regular
access by pier-and-door partitions. Interspersed through palaces are
rectangular sunken chambers for offerings. While a large portion of
the temple was dedicated storage, small rooms stored precious objects
or religious equipment. Temples also included backstage rooms:
dressing and preparing rooms for priestesses, communal dining rooms,
kitchens, and several separate suites. Many people worked in the
background to realize the elaborate ritual scenes found in many of
its frescoes, and those people needed to eat. The north east section
of the labyrinth contains many simple cups and was most likely an
area where meals were prepared or eaten, and the area south of the
court was most likely a domestic area.
|
Reconstructed domestic section of the palace at Knossos, south of the court |
|
A large stack of common simple conical cups from the palace at Arkhanes, Crete |
|
A
room in the NT period palace of Gournia with hundreds of cups, sealed
after a celebration ca. 1,700 BCE. The feast and its deposition is
considered by the excavator John Younger to be a kind of foundation
deposit
|
Daily
life in the temple also necessitated multiple lavatories and baths.
MM and LM period plumbing was astonishingly similar to modern and
medieval systems.
“The
water, which was conducted from the roof and the light areas, was
gathered into cisterns and from these conducted down the tiles to the
baths and latrines, from which it was again discharged to great stone
sewers, many of which were large enough to admit a man. These were
connected with huge drain-heads and every provision was made for the
excess surface water, just as we to-day have built our storm sewers.
Every joint in the tile drains was held together by cement and the
floors of the rooms were laid in gypsum.” -
W. J. Corrigan
There
is evidence of a “flushing” toilet in the labyrinth, as the
toilet was connected to a drainage shaft and would have been
“flushed” with either rainwater or by (servants) pouring water
down the channel.
“On
the face of the gypsum slab to the right is is a groove for a small
wooden post for the support of a seat about 57 c.m. above the floor.
Outside the doorway of the latrine is a flag, sloped towards a
semi-circular hole forming a sink and from this opens a small duct
leading to the main drain. The aperture leading to the main drain
deviates from the centre of the seat thus leaving room on the right
for some vessel for flushing the basin. As an anticipation of
scientific methods of sanitation the system of which we have here the
record, has been attained by few nations even at the present time.”
- Arthur
Evans
There
is evidence that stone sewer channels remained in use for hundreds of
years with only minor repairs. Cisterns were built with water
resistant plaster.
|
Drawing of an elaborate Minoan bathtub |
|
A simpler Minoan bathtub from around 1,350 BCE |
|
A Minoan toilet |
|
A drawing of a flushed toilet at Knossos |
Inter-fitting
4”-6” wide terracotta pipes were common and sometimes buried down
to 11 feet deep, such technology was only superseded much later by
iron age lead pipes. In an act which can only be described as the
result of trial and error, the pipes did not run under the living
spaces of the palace, but under specific hallways. Cracks and leaking
must have been an issue, yet terracotta piping is surprisingly
effective, as the tapered edges create a seal when under water
pressure.
|
A piece of Knossian terracotta pipe, with handles for carrying |
|
A piece of revealed Knossian terracotta pipe protected by a grate, by Peggy Sugarman |
The
steep grade of the countryside around Knossos allowed its plumbers to
create an effective drainage system for the temple's many lavatories.
There were three in the east wing alone, all connected to a single
main sewer. Professional masons constructed a main sewer, and
attached to this central structure were four stone shafts leading
from the upper stories. Such shafts acted as trash receptacles,
ventilation, and light wells in addition to their primary sewage
purpose. By the mid MM period Knossos had drainage systems in both
the domestic quarter and by the north entrance.
|
A stone drainage channel at Knossos |
|
A sewer outfall on an exterior wall of the temple at Knossos |
|
Picture of a Minoan drainage channel underneath a walk way, Knossos |
The
“Queen's Bathroom”, so named by Arthur Evans, has beautifully
decorated walls and features water jugs, washing basins, and a
bathtub. The 5 foot long terracotta tub is painted with a design
involving reeds. The tub has no drain, so emptying it was probably
done by servants. In the floor of this room is a chute designed
specifically for this purpose, connected to the main drain.
|
“The Queen's Bathroom” at Knossos |
|
A reconstruction of “The Queen's Bathroom” |
The
Central Court
|
The central court at Phaistos now |
All
temples were centered around an open air court, most famously used
for bull leaping. At Phaistos this court was bounded by doorways
which could be closed, blocking off some sections of the court, and
at Mallia a large door could close off the north colonnade. It is not
known whether this was done for ritual, privacy, or protection. The
east side of the court at Mallia had railings attached to wooden
posts, creating the division between the arena and spectators. This
is supported by frescoes at Knossos which show a priestess leaning
against a three tiered wooden railing. Lining the west end of the
court are multiple frescoes, highlighting the court's symbolic
importance as the heart of the structure.
|
The central court at Knossos now |
|
The central court pointed out at Knossos |
The
rooms which directly opened onto the central court were designed
either to be more important or simply to hold more foot traffic. At
Phaistos two primary chambers open onto the court, both having bench
altars and presumably these two chambers were ritually related to
bull leaping or other courtly activities conducted in the court. The
most prominent room off of Knossos' court is the throne room, which
itself includes bench altars. Multiple rooms in temples contained
such altars, with at least one being made of gypsum. These bench
altars may have had offerings, votive figurines, or larger statuettes
placed on them. While they are geographically near to the court, it
is entirely impossible to know how the rituals which took place in
these rooms were related to bull leaping or any other court activity.
It is possible that different activities which took place in the
court were linked to rituals in separate rooms.
|
The west end of the court at Knossos |
|
A cultic procession at Knossos |
From
the Entrances to the Central Court
The
labyrinth had 7-8 entrances, yet strangely none are obviously its
main thoroughfare. Each one is blended into its section of the wall,
none of them are grandiose nor even share the same design. While each
entrance connects to the rest of the structure, they all funnel to
the central court.
|
Wooden model of the temple at Knossos |
This
was by no means a straight line, and to the uninitiated it must have
seemed absolutely random, mysterious, and religious. It must have
been part of the experience, possibly involving levels of initiation
as in many classical period mystery religions. To the average Cretan,
if they were permitted in if only to the central court, it must have
been an awe inspiring experience. It was after all, designed to
fulfill Minoan society's needs, to inspire reverence in your deity
through monumental architecture. How much this also inspired loyalty
to ones' Wanax is an interesting question. Individual Sumerian Kings
struggled slowly for hundreds of years to usurp the power of each of
their city state's theocratic cabal, did the same fluctuating
tug-of-war riddle Minoan society?
|
The columned bridge at the south entrance of Knossos |
|
Another version of the columned bridge at the south entrance of Knossos |
As
the power of urban temples grew, it began to dominate local shrines
and sanctuaries spread across the countryside. In doing so, it began
to replicate the power of such places through its architecture. As
the power shifted from the countryside to the urban centers,
religious importance shifted as well. Subterranean rooms such as the
Hall of the Double Axes at Knossos evoke the dark power of hidden
cave sanctuaries. The Throne Room with its stone peak surrounded by
landscape frescoes evokes the windswept glory of peak sanctuaries.
Prior to the OT period, a devotee would go to such natural places
like caves, peaks, and forests to praise their god. But now it was
all packaged together in one convenient location, under princely
oversight.
|
Knossos courtyard at the bottom of a stairway, by yurdigital.com |
Bull
Leaping
|
The Bull Leaping figurine, made of bronze between 1,550-1,450 BCE on Crete |
A
primary activity of the central court was to sport bull leaping
events. It is important to note that the images we have of bull
leapers represent different stages of different events, and even then
only an idealized version of that event. It was complex enough that
teams would have certainly rehearsed feats or routines. Such
acrobatics would have been intended to dazzle spectators, with
somersaults around the bull and even over its back. This is commonly
represented in Minoan art with a seemingly complacent bull simply
standing by, but realistically that would have been near impossible.
Some depictions of bull leaping show a possible standard practice,
which was to have 2-4 people hold down the horns for such dangerous
jumps. This jump was certainly the primary attraction as they would
flip headfirst over the bull's horns to land on their feet behind the
animal. Even more fantastical is a statuette from Rethymnon showing a
jumper performing this headfirst leap and somehow landing on their
feet on the bull's back.
|
An ivory figurine of an acrobat leaping over a bull, it was originally attached to a bull figurine by a thin gold stand which can be faintly seen hanging off the bottom of the figurine |
|
A diagram of a bull leaping maneuver |
In
the corners of some courts, such as at Phaistos, a raised block was
possibly a step for the jumpers. Acrobats are shown in Minoan art
aside from bulls as well, such as on various seals where acrobats
perform handstands. A gold hilt from Mallia shows an acrobat doing a
backflip. Performances involving bulls or not were both performed by
skilled professionals, they were most likely choreographed to
heighten the audience's experience. It is unknown where exactly
acrobats performs when seen isolated on seals, but their common
depiction in Minoan life attests to their wide notoriety.
|
A seal from Mallia, Crete, showing an acrobat balancing over a sword |
|
The acrobat on a gold roundel from Mallia |
The
evidence of railings (even up to three layers) at around courts
points to the danger inherent in such practices, even with four
people holding a bull down things are bound to go wrong. On the Boxer
rhyton, one unlucky acrobat is seen being gored by a bull, showing
that this scene of was common enough in the Minoan mind to be
represented in art. In an age without modern medicine, grievous
injuries were all the more deadly.
|
The only depiction a bull leaping related injury in Minoan art, on the Boxer Rhyton |
Youthful
skilled entertainers could make a career out of dangerous spectacles
then, just as people still do today. Famous acrobats were probably
celebrities, fulfilling a similar role to classical Roman gladiators
and modern racecar drivers. An acrobat using a springboard to leap
over a stationary “horse” has become a common modern trope in
acrobatics, an interesting piece of continuity in principle with
bronze age bull leapers.
|
Bull leaping has not gone out of fashion. Modern recortadores still practice the dangerous sport, giving credence to depictions of the figurines leaping unaided |
|
A recortador doing a back flip |
|
A recortador finishing with a handstand, one upping the Minoans! |
|
The Bull Leaping fresco from Avaris, Egypt. Done in Minoan style with Minoan artists but in the capital of the Hyksos kingdom in occupied lower Egypt. One dating even suggests it may be older than the Knossian taureador fresco, but that is contested |
Scribes
and Tablets
The primary tablet stashes
are at Knossos and Pylos. Each stash is comprised of a single archive
of tablets, with a new archive being drawn up each year. The archives
found at cities were most likely records of the operation of its
final year. These tablets were mostly itemized lists and produce
documentation. These records were written and read by fully literate
scribes, although probably many people who dealt with writing on a
more common basis were semi-literate out of practicality and
familiarity with certain pictographs. Some bronze age Mesopotamian
Kings were literate even funding libraries, but many others delegated
those administrative tasks to their scribes and did not need the
skill to exercise their authority. It is unknown whether Aegean Kings
faced a similar situation, although it certainly was helpful to read
the treaties and financial records of which you had oversight.
|
A tablet with Linear A from Zakros |
|
A fragment of Linear A writing |
|
A cylindrical seal using Linear A |
The best preserved tablets at
Knossos are about the production of wool. The temple had hundreds of
such tablets, which fully explain its bureaucratic handling of both
wool artisans and its wool stockpile. While tithes may have began as
only a social obligation, by the LM period the temple set precise
wool production targets along with noting each herd's population.
Each herd is given with 0-2 names, presumably of any owners of those
herds. Herds with two owners were probably the shepherd and another
owner. Herds with one owner were solely owned by its shepherd, and
herds without names were either owned by the King or had been ordered
into stacks to show ownership (instead of writing the name of the
owner on the tablet). The individual shepherds and wealthier herd
owners were semi-independent, but also directly responsible to the
palace-temple. This almost feudal system of allegiance and
obligations was managed by the Wanax through those records his
bureaucrats drew up. With the invention of record keeping there is
also the simultaneous invention of written corruption, and the Wanax
and his scribes in their “bronze tower” may at times been
disconnected from the actual health of the economy (as seen by the
shepherds) at the village level.
|
Fragments of Linear B writing |
Once wool had been collected
it was turned into textiles, with the amount, type, and producer
specified by the palace-temple. Most production was at Knossos
directly overseen by the temple in the east wing, which contained a
large textile workshop staffed by unnamed women and children. Some
tablets suggest these workers were paid in grain rations, and that
they had supervisors. The child textile workers were labeled
“larger”, “smaller”, and “under instruction”. At Pylos,
the temple similarly used unnamed women and children as in-temple
textile workers, but also gave their specific occupation and
sometimes country of origin. Most of the occupations given to these
workers were menial jobs such as spinning wool, grinding grain,
carding flax. The scale of this operation is staggering, tablets from
both Knossos and Pylos mention over 300-600 different workers, Andrea
Salimbeti cites 700 women, 400 girls, and 300 boys.
It is not known whether these
workers were free, debt slaves, or chattel slaves, but in tablets it
is mentioned that the workers “belong to them” (the
priestesses?). Enslaved women and children suggest predatory raiding,
where the men in a settlement were killed and the rest of the
population were enslaved. The countries of origin of these workers
would have shown where they had come from, most are from the coast of
Anatolia: Knidos, Miletos, Lemnos, Halikarnassos, Chios, and Aswija
(possibly Assuwa a Hittite region based in classical Lydia). On a
Knossian tablet and on PY Ep 705.6 slaves are mentioned from Toroja,
and on another tablet a slave came from Thebes. The Mycenaean word
for these people is lawiaiai (la-wi-ai-ai) or “captives”, which
is the word Homer uses to describe the woman Achilles takes in a raid
at Lyrnessos south of Troy in the Iliad. While it is still unknown
whether these workers were enslaved or not, there is evidence that at
least some of the workers in the palace-temple were slaves (at least
on the mainland).
While
hundreds of workers labored in the textile workshop scribes kept
detailed records of the influx and outflow of material. Such a high
position within the temple hierarchy demanded exclusivity, and there
were far fewer record keepers than textile laborers. An analysis of
the tablets found at Knossos shows that there were at least 70
scribes working in the temple by 1,380 BCE. Scribes in Mesopotamia
during the 3rd
millennium BCE were the children (almost all sons) of the wealthy and
were sent to rigorous scribal schools to learn the profession. Once
they graduated from such schools, they were employed throughout daily
life. Some worked at temples as record keepers, but many others
worked locally to help business owners write documents. Mesopotamian
scribes played an important role in many aspects of society, from
crafting adoption documents to mathematically dividing up a deceased
parent's estate for their children. It is unknown whether Minoan
scribes underwent such rigorous training and were so integrated into
society, but both Minoan and Mesopotamian scribes worked in their
society's halls of power, in close contact to nobility and their
Kings.
Scripts
Scribes during the OT and NT
period wrote in three scripts, possibly four depending on how you
want to classify the Phaistos disk. The original script on the island
was Cretan hieroglyphics, developed independently although with some
possible eastern inspiration. It was used on seals about 100 years
prior to the first temples. The second script was Linear A, developed
out of Cretan hieroglyphics at Phaistos, then spread across the
island. It was used on seals and tablets by scribes in the OT and NT
periods to write their native (non Indo-European) Minoan language.
The third script was Linear B, which was used solely to write their
Indo-European Proto-Greek during the LM period, and was introduced
from mainland Greece. The possible fourth is only on the Phaistos
disk. This tablet was made around 1,700 BCE (at Phaistos) and shares
some symbols with Linear A signs from the Arkalochori Axe, but most
of the symbols on the disk are unique. The disk is also unique in
that many of the symbols are replicas, having been made (probably)
into small seals and then repetitively stamped into the disk creating
an early form of block printing.
|
A few seals using Cretan hieroglyphics |
|
The Phaistos disk |
Strangely enough Cretan
hieroglyphics were not discontinued as newer forms gained popularity.
Such glyphs are found on tablets throughout the MM period and from
the Theran eruption (around 1,470 BCE). Parallel secular and
religious languages exist in many cultures, and the use of
hieroglyphics and Linear A may be another example of such a cultural
developmental scenario. Linear A was used until around the 1,400s BCE
when it was supplanted by Linear B (proto-Greek). Since Linear A was
not the predecessor of mainland Greek it most likely was used to
write the native Cretan language, although it is still untranslated.
By the LM period Linear B is found across Crete as well as on the
mainland, Helladic culture had infiltrated the small island. Linear B
was primarily used for accounting, inventories, and religious
dedications, although the vast majority of tablets were lost. Linear
B contains lists of people, places, commodities, and deities, but no
commentary on such things. Since Linear A is still untranslated, it
is possible that such commentary may still survive albeit locked in
as-of-yet mysterious symbols.
|
A map of Linear A finds outside of Crete |
|
The difficulty of translating Linear A, multiple possible meanings behind sign 301 |
Tablets are only found
accidentally, it is the texts that were destroyed in fires which
ironically survived to this day. Tablets buried in rubble deep within
collapsed temples are the only literature from the Minoans which
survived the intervening thousands of years. It is a terrible shame
that no actual literature has ever been recovered. Clay cups have
been found with ink, and Cretans were known to have parchment. Sadly
the entirety of that form of literature along with any Minoan oral
traditions have been erased by the cruel twists of history. It is a
seemingly random fact that only temple records were preserved, as
other forms of literature besides accounting were also (presumably)
written down but were simply stored elsewhere and destroyed. The vast
majority of tablets from Knossos and Pylos are from single
repositories, these caches were the records of the previous year,
with new records being drawn up yearly. Thus the records from Knossos
only accurately detail its last year of operation, leaving the entire
remainder of its history a mystery. What has been found is an
extremely tiny fraction of the total records of that society, this
scenario is similar to our records of Greek literature as we only
have 45 full plays when 1,000s were mentioned in passing.
|
Linear B syllabary |
|
Linear B pictograms |
|
Linear B words. Top: Non phonetic spelling. Middle: Actual pronunciation. Bottom: English translation |
|
Linear B vowel diphthong dropping. Top: The word's written form. Middle: The word's pronunciation. Bottom: English translation |
|
Linear B logograms. Top: the symbol's original pronunciation. Middle: English translation. Bottom: The symbols actual pronunciation |
|
Linear B symbols showing sex differentiation. Two dashed lines symbolize male, and two body lines symbolize female |
The eruption of Vesuvius in
79 CE buried a private library at a Roman villa near Herculaneum.
While the texts were entirely burnt and disintegrate if touched by a
human hand, modern scanning equipment invented thousands of years
after the Roman era can decipher their faint symbols. The texts were
packed into crates and were in the process of being evacuated by the
owner when the pyroclastic flow froze them in time. If the scrolls
had been successfully evacuated and taken elsewhere surely they would
have been destroyed somehow. In this unexpected twist of fate, many
Roman and Minoan texts were probably saved and hidden elsewhere
during disasters, only to be destroyed. Individuals who tried to save
their precious literature in turn destroyed it, and that which was
destroyed by fire in turn became the only survived writing from their
entire cultures.
|
Villa of the Papyri, Herculaneum |
As
the temple structure collapsed in the 11-12th
centuries BCE, the profession of the scribe and the keeping of such
intricate records were no longer necessary. The old forms of writing
died out along with palatial bureaucratic titles. A
few hundred years later when Cretans (and Greeks) would take up
writing en masse again, it would be based off of a foreign Phoenician
alphabet instead of their ancestral Linear B.
References
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteI am forever in love with Cretan architecture. I am always surprised, because it is current. They fit perfectly, with environmental and ecological concerns. Virtually in its entirety, its gently dazzling construction, would receive several green stamps.
Deletea wonderful work. Thanks a lot :)
ReplyDeleteVery thorough research. Enjoyed reading! Thank you!
ReplyDeleteThis is an absolute wonderful post,well researched and documented. The illustrations are the best I have seen Thank you for sharing. Love all the information with regards to the Linear B tablets which I have been studying for the past 5 years.
ReplyDelete